Owner's Response: Thank you for taking the time to write such a detailed review. Let me address a few things. I was actually in Florida for my niece's graduation, so I am not sure what you felt about continually being watched. The door is left unopened sometimes for new arrivals, so I am sure that was the case. Certainly if I had been there doing last-minute stocking or something, I would have welcomed you rather than slipping out the back door unnoticed. The lead has always been around the tree for use when folks bring there pets. It was not placed there to "demonstrate that your departure was being awaited and observed". I don't know what to say about the dock and the water. She has only a slight winter view of the lake, true, and it is a gentle walk to the water, (rather than steep like many). We share a path with the neighbor, (who does not live there and only uses it a few times a year), but I am sorry that they were there over the holiday weekend. The single-slip covered dock has 10-12 feet of water (even now when we are down 7') and is used on a regular basis. I just painted it last year, but I will definitely check it and see what looks un-maintained. It has a swim dock (side space), a swim ladder for lake access, a dock box to hold a few items so, I am not sure what you were expecting. The cove is wide and beautiful and never stagnant. As far as Mabel goes, I know that I say she is simple, no granite, hardwoods or stainless steel , but she is neat and clean and she has a coffee pot, toaster and crockpot. Since I had just emptied the cupboards and ran the dishes in the dishwasher, I am surprised to learn that you thought that you saw dirty dishes. I will definitely check this out as well. We have a very thorough cleaning crew, so this will be addressed.The couch and chairs are white leather, and the carpets were professionally cleaned just before your arrival. We actually take a lot of pride in delivering Mabel in clean and cute condition. I have been meaning to re-paint and add new flooring, but Mabel is booked solid and there has not been time, so I agree, she could use a face lift. You might actually enjoy Hope/#1046222. I have spent the last 18 months preparing for vrbo and everything is brand new. ..or try the Ritz.. In conclusion, I must agree that Mabel has had quite a long run and is looking rather tired. She will be retiring as of September 15th of this year and will be replaced by a real cottage. Thanks again. Better luck with your future travel decisions.