Located on the lake, this 4-bedroom vacation home accommodates 8 guests and features 3 bathrooms. It offers lake views and outdoor areas including a porch, patio, and deck. Enjoy paddleboarding, mountain biking, tubing, and game walks nearby. Explore attractions like Goodyear Lake and the Susquehanna River while enjoying the adventure theme.
Highlights
Paddleboard available
A rare find — hit the water on a paddleboard right here.
Discover nearby landmarks
Close to Susquehanna River
4 bedrooms3 bathroomsSleeps 8
Popular amenities
Patio
Internet
Barbecue grill
Washer/dryer
Onsite parking available
Air-conditioning
Explore the area
Maryland, NY
Goodyear Lake
Place, Goodyear Lake
1 min walk
State University of New York-Oneonta
Place, State University of New York-Oneonta
16 min drive
Cooperstown All Star Village Fields
Place, Cooperstown All Star Village Fields
25 min drive
Where you'll sleep
4 bedrooms (sleeps 8)
Bedroom 1
1 Queen Bed
Bedroom 2
1 Queen Bed
Bedroom 3
1 Double Bed
Bedroom 4
2 Single Beds
3 bathrooms
Bathroom 1
Toilet · Shower only
Bathroom 2
Toilet · Shower only
Bathroom 3
Bathtub or shower · Toilet
Spaces
Deck or patio
Porch or lanai
Kitchen
Garden
Dining area
About this property
New Lake House near Cooperstown
Please note: Our rental schedule is set to the schedules of the two local baseball parks in the area, Cooperstown All-Star Village and Cooperstown Dreams Park. They are six-day tournaments. Our calendar is set up in six-day intervals to go along with the baseball parks.
Cancellation Policy: If we receive a cancellation notice 90 days or more before the arrival date, the rental payment will be refunded, less $300. If we receive a cancellation notice less than 90 days before the arrival date, there will be no refund.
Have friends/family looking for a place? View VRBO listing #9085278 for our other house, also located on Goodyear Lake.
Enjoy 50' of water-front property on Goodyear Lake near Cooperstown, NY. The house is located 10 miles (An easy 15 min. drive) from Dreams Park in Cooperstown and 13 miles (An easy 18 min. drive) to The All-Star Village in Oneonta. The Lake House is a favorite for families coming to the area for these two attractions.
FEATURES -This home is truly one-of-a-kind! -The home is built from a hand-hewed timber-framed barn -The original barn was built in the 1830s by English settlers in the Catskill Mountains (Gilboa, NY) -Features exposed timbers in all rooms -All furniture is custom crafted (beds, end-tables, kitchen cabinets, butcher-block island, vanities, light fixtures, etc.) -Includes a vanity crafted from a wine barrel, hay-track light feature, original hardware for barn-sliding doors -You will never stay in a house like this, this is a showpiece that will be fun to stay in and show off to friends -50' of water-front property -House is just 20' off of Goodyear Lake (344 acres) -Canoe and life vests are provided -Boats, kayaks, paddle boards, etc. are available to rent locally
LAYOUT -4 Bedrooms, 3 Full Bathrooms -Large closets -Open floor plan in the living space, perfect for family/teams - Air Conditioning in all bedrooms and living space -Sleeps 8 -WI-FI throughout -Parking for 4 cars -Includes ALL linens and cleaning supplies -Washer/dryer and laundry supplies included
MAIN FLOOR -Full wall of glass doors -Spectacular views, you can often spot bald eagles... -270 square-foot deck just 20’ from the water! -Deck includes patio furniture and grill
Kitchen-- -A chef’s dream kitchen! -Large kitchen with granite counters -A fieldstone vent-a-hood and stainless steel appliances -A 48' Viking stove with double convection ovens, 6 burners and a grill -Features a hand-crafted butcher-block island -10’ peninsula that seats 5
Living Room- -Large living room with 70” TV -24’ vaulted ceilings -Hand-scrapped maple floors -A/C
UPSTAIRS -Master Suite with queen bed and full bathroom -Bathroom features a large shower with duel shower heads (one rain-shower head) -Original 180-year-old reclaimed barn-wood floors
DOWNSTAIRS -Bedroom #2 - Queen bed -Bedroom #3 -full bed (unique in that it features a light post crafted from a birch tree) -Bedroom #4 -two twin beds -Very LARGE bathroom with water closet, 8’ vanity, and double sinks
LOCATION -10 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park -15 miles to Cooperstown -12 to All-Star Village -10 to Baseball World
Our prices include all fees. No hidden fees.
Add dates for prices
Have a question?
AI iconBetaBeta
Get instant answers with AI powered search of property information and reviews.
1. If we receive a cancellation notice 90 days prior to the arrival date, the rental payment will be refunded, less 10% of the Full Rental Fee.
2. If we receive a cancellation notice less than 90 days prior to the arrival date, there will be no refund.
Covid-19 Update. If Dreams Field or The All Star Village cancels due to Covid-19 we will refund you 80% of your rental up until 30 days prior to stay.
Important information
You need to know
Property # 3635161
This property is managed by a private host (a party not acting within their trade, business or profession). EU consumer law, including the right of withdrawal, will not apply to your booking. The cancellation policy set by the private host will cover your booking.
Extra-person charges may apply and vary depending on property policy
Government-issued photo identification and a credit card, debit card or cash deposit may be required at check-in for incidental charges
Special requests are subject to availability upon check-in and may incur additional charges; special requests cannot be guaranteed
On-site parties or group events are strictly prohibited
Host has indicated that there is a carbon monoxide detector on the property
Host has indicated that there is a smoke detector on the property
Safety features at this property include a fire extinguisher and a deadlock
This property has outdoor spaces, such as balconies, patios and terraces, which may not be suitable for children; if you have any concerns, we recommend contacting the property prior to your arrival to confirm that they can accommodate you in a suitable room
About the area
Maryland
Located in Maryland, this holiday home is in the mountains and on the waterfront. Bear Pond Winery and Cooperstown Brewing Company are worth checking out if an activity is on the agenda, while those looking for area attractions can visit Rail Explorers Cooperstown and Foothills Performing Arts Center. Anderson Center for the Arts and Bowl Winkles are also worth visiting. Jet skiing and kayaking offer great chances to get out on the surrounding water, or you can seek out an adventure with hiking/biking trails and mountain biking nearby.
State University of New York-Oneonta - 16 min drive - 18.8 km
Hartwick College - 17 min drive - 18.9 km
Cooperstown All Star Village Fields - 25 min drive - 27.1 km
Restaurants
Brooks House of Bar-B-Q's - 11 min drive
Burger King - 15 min drive
Applebee's Grill + Bar - 15 min drive
62 Maple St. - 15 min drive
Panera Bread - 14 min drive
Frequently asked questions
Is New Lake House near Cooperstown pet-friendly?
No, pets are not allowed at this property.
How much is parking at New Lake House near Cooperstown?
On-site parking is available at the property.
What time is check-in at New Lake House near Cooperstown?
Check-in begins at 4:00 PM.
What time is check-out at New Lake House near Cooperstown?
Checkout is at 10:00 AM.
Where is New Lake House near Cooperstown located?
Situated on the waterfront, this holiday home is steps away from Susquehanna River and Goodyear Lake. Robert V. Riddell State Park is 2.5 mi (4 km) away.
Reviews
9.8
Exceptional
Reviews are presented in chronological order, subject to a moderation process, and verified unless otherwise labelled.
The property was great! The house was fully stocked with everything we needed for the week and the communication with the hosts was excellent. Would definitely recommend staying here!
We stayed here while at Cooperstown and it was perfect. An easy 15 minute drive to Dreams Park and the ability to have the kids swim in the lake in between games was huge! Very large kitchen, comfortable beds, and a large living room. Would stay here again!
Perfect setup for extended family on a baseball trip
Comfortable and pleasant, convenient to Cooperstown All-Star Village. Plenty of restaurant options around and Cooperstown is a short drive away. Lovely setting overlooking the water.
This house and property were perfect for our week at Cooperstown. We loved grilling on the back porch (overlooking the lake) and the kids did some fishing too! Main area is open and great for cooking/spending time together. Would recommend this house to others for sure.
Issy was a GREAT host - seamless checkin / checkout process, house was as expected, right on the lake. We highly recommend getting a pontoon boat and taking it out on the lake - very quiet lake for late June, and warm enough to take a brisk swim in. Houses are a little close, as expected for a lake community, but incredibly quiet and peaceful. Highly recommend for a quick excursion from the city.
Stayed 7 nights in Jun 2021
Response from VrboOwner on 29 Jul 2021
Thank you for staying. It was a pleasure having you stay at the house.
Verified review
8/10 Good
Lauren B.
24 Aug 2025
Liked: Check-in, communication, listing accuracy
Owner was easy to contact and quick to come and fix a plumbing issue. Location is very congested but also very pretty on the water. Only thing we didn’t like were the heavy barn/sliding door on the bedroom. Hard to be quiet when others are sleeping.
The house was great for our Cooperstown stay. Loved being on the lake and the canoe was an added benefit for our boys! They caught fish and kept busy. The A/C was amazing house stayed cold and it was a hot week! Thanks so much
The house is as it is represented. The woodwork and fixtures are unique and quality to make for a cozy stay. Issy was great, no complaints and would recommend.
We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at this lakefront property. It was the perfect size for 6 of us with a few rotating family guests. A 19 minute drive to All Star Village and 30 minutes to Cooperstown. Very clean and comfortable. Issy was very attentive and communication was simple. Would stay here agin for sure.
This was an amazing house & a wonderful stay! The house was clean & comfortable. The view from inside or on the deck was beautiful. The details in the house are spot on. Plus it was close enough to dreams park that if you have a few hours between games, you could go back & relax. The hosts were great too, & got back with any questions quickly. Highly recommend staying here!
This house is was a great place to stay for a week at Dreamspark. Not to far away and a nice easy drive to get there. The house was spectacular. We had a minor bee issue but the owner took care of it that morning. My other kids were able to fish from the dock in the down time. I would recommend this place to anyone.
We stayed at this property while my son was playing baseball at Cooperstown All-Star Dreams. It is a fantastic property on the lake that offers canoeing and fishing. We enjoyed both with my other kids while not at the ballpark.
The property is true to the manner in which it is advertised. We would recommend it to anyone looking for a place to stay in the Cooperstown/Oneonta, NY area.
This is a comfortable home built for guests to enjoy. Right on the lake. Unique style. Super functional and nice. The host was very nice and responsive.
The lake house is an absolutely beautiful property. We were in the Cooperstown area for a week of baseball at Cooperstown All Star Village. My concern upon booking was how far the house seemed from CASV, but it was less than 20 mins away. It was easy to get from the lake house to the stores in Oneonta to CASV. It was also so easy to head up to Cooperstown for a visit to the Baseball Hall of Fame.
The lake house itself is gorgeous and very spacious. The deck looks directly onto the lake. It was such a peaceful place to have morning coffee and watch as ducks swam by.
Issy was very responsive and patient with my questions, before and during our stay. (Thank you!!)
Overall, we loved our time there and would definitely stay here again. If we're lucky enough to come back again, we'll definitely make use of the canoe and/or rent a pontoon boat.
Stayed 7 nights in Jul 2021
About the host
Hosted by Issy Durkin
This house was built by the owners- a career builder/designer and a local teacher. This house is the result of years of experience building custom homes; specializing in historic timber frames.
Why they chose this property
-One of the reasons we chose to build on this site is because it is very close to the water - and we've also dreamed of owning a waterfront property. Most houses on the lake are 2 or 3 or more stories above the water level with numerous flights of stair-we're just 20 feet from the water. -Goodyear Lake appealed to us because it's picturesque 370 acre lake, not extremely active (there is no public launch) and is very quiet and relaxing. -We choose the Cooperstown area-not only because of its location to the baseball hall of fame, but also because of the many other features it has to offer. Within a short distance, there are several shops, restaurants, parks, and hiking/outdoor recreation facilities.
What makes this property unique
-50 feet of picturesque waterfront includes a generous area for outdoor seating and grill Swimming and fishing available from the dock -Canoe available for use -Newly built- the fall of 2013 -The home is built from a hand-hewed timber-framed barn. Original barn built in the 1830’s by English settlers in the Catskill Mountains (Gilboa, NY) -Features exposed timbers in all rooms All furniture is custom crafted (beds, end-tables, kitchen cabinets, butcher-block island, vanities, light fixtures etc.)
Languages:
English
Premier Host
They consistently provide great experiences for their guests