Verified
10/10 Excellent
Zack T.
1 Jun 2026
Liked: Cleanliness, check-in, communication, location, listing accuracy
Exceeded All Expectations -Perfect Couples Retreat!Longer review than I typically leave but since this is a new property, I figured I’d provide additional detail. Our party of four couples just spent an extended weekend at Margaret’s place, and it was the ultimate mini-getaway that exceeded our expectations. We were actually planning on stopping over at Margaret’s place and then heading out to a hotel in Montauk but we liked it so much here that we extended our stay for the whole four nights / five days. The house is brand new, modern, beautifully decorated and immaculately clean. It truly felt like we were the very first guests to ever stay there! The Highlights of Our Stay:Thoughtful Touches: The kitchen was fully stocked. Margaret even left K-Cups to get us started and a welcome bottle of rosé, which was an amazing refresher after our drive from NYC.Incredible Backyard: We spent most of our time lounging by the pool and grilling at home. The garage was packed with plenty of pool floats, loungers and fun lawn games. The newly installed paver patio (not pictured in the listing photos) made the outdoor hangout space even better.Perfect Location: Hampton Bays offered the ideal balance of privacy and convenience. It was a much easier drive from NYC than staying further east like we have in the past, yet we were just a short drive from ocean beaches, local spots and Southampton where we went for dinner. We loved it so much that we will definitely be back later this summer!
Zack T.
Stayed 1 night in May 2026
