Pros: Owner/manager (Max) could not have been more helpful - super responsive, helpful and available at any time we needed help. Really, really appreciate that! Location was wonderful - easy access to beach or sound. Lots of good restaurants nearby, as well as easy grocery shopping,etc.
Slight Con: Some prominent stains on carpeting upstairs (although I guess that may be expected with a pet-friendly rental). Yard was pretty overgrown, but was nice to have a fenced in yard. I'm sure this was just my oversight, but I didn't realize the property was a duplex until we arrived, just in case that makes a difference to anyone.
Overall: Would stay there again, especially if Max is in charge. :)