I get it .. house is ocean front and gets beat up by the weather and by renters. But this house had an excessive amount of deferred maintenance. One bed was broken. The refrigerator door had all shelves removed and hence had no door storage. There were five (not one, five) lightbulbs that were out that needed replacement. The trash can holder in the cabinetry was broken -- when you pulled it out to throw away the trash, the entire wooden fixture fell onto the kitchen floor. We had rain and there were major leaks in the main living room (we head to put a trash can underneath it) and the first floor bedroom. In the kitchen, there were no kitchen linens, no potholders and no metal spatula for grilling. I could go on and on, but you get the picture.
House was clean, location was great, but with all the deferred maintenance and just poor attention to fundamentals (lightbulbs, kitchen utensils), we give it a three.