My wife and I stayed here for a week in August. We've been to Door County many times, but I guess we prefer Fish Creek. In my opinion it's centrally located, and a bit less congested than Sister Bay. This rental is perfect for a couple, although you could sleep 6. We don't eat out every night, so it's great to have a fully stocked kitchen. This place had more than most, as some rentals only have a few basic things. So that was cool. It's an end unit that backs up to Fish Creek, the actual creek...not the town. So a pretty cool view back there, and super private. Beds are comfy, everything works, and you will love this place!
Fish Creek, the town...not the creek, is super walkable. As far as restaurants two of my faves are Wild Tomato & Loft. All in all we had a great week here!