The good: location, lots of rooms, nice view from the deck. The bad: the house is tired. When taking a shower any water usage in other parts of the house affect the temp in the shower, which is not enjoyable. Beds were a bit firm for our liking. Knives need sharpening badly, non-stick pans flaking the non-stick. BBQs are charcoal (no propane) and there were 3 bags on site, all empty, giving us the illusion that when it was time to grill, we'd have charcoal. (in other STR we have stayed, propane or charcoal has always been provided). Screen door in master out to private deck was broken, so couldn't open slider and enjoy Yosemite fresh mountain air. Furniture in LR is all covered with protectors.
Re: cleanliness. There was a big spill of what was maybe vanilla ice cream out on the deck when we arrived. Too many dead bugs scattered around the house to count - and many had been there definitely since before the last cleaning. Gross stuff spilled and dried in the kitchen utensil drawer. The large grill was so dirty it was unusable, but the smaller one was good enough. The oven was atrociously dirty and gross. (I have pics of every one of these items.)
We stayed in the primary br upstairs, which is right over the garage. Something in the garage turns on what seemed like every 3 minutes, which made it annoying when trying to fall asleep. Maybe water well pump or?
A small note for those who might bring small children. The stairway rails, although to code when the house was built, have not been brought up to current code and the spacing between the rails is wide, probably about 6" or more. My 4 yo could easily get his head through. Just a warning...
The house is roomy and the view is good, but unless the owner is willing to put some money into the house to provide more standard comfort, and have better cleaning, we would not stay again or recommend to friends.