Many aspects of this property were terrific: the location is perfect, it had plenty of space for a very large group, Carl was generally responsive and helpful, and instructions for getting there, rules, etc were laid out clearly and helpfully. There was an awesome collection of beach toys and chairs which made it a blast for our kids.
There are a few aspects of the property that were lacking though.
Zero bikes were functional. I will grant that there’s a disclaimer in the welcome book saying the bikes might not be operational, but there wasn’t even a bike pump in the garage and the bikes had clearly not been maintained for a long time. If the owner is not going to maintain the bikes, they should be thrown out.
Many items in the home were in poor repair. The fridge door was broken (which Carl did alert us to prior to our stay) and when we got there I found a giant pool of water in the fridge that I had to clean up. Many dresser drawers in the kids rooms were falling apart. Half the billiard cues had their felt tips torn off.
The wifi login information posted to VRBO was incorrect (the correct network/password info was in the welcome book) and it took a day for me to find the correct information.
All in all, we did have a great time, but I would have expected that, given the rates we paid, the house could have been a bit more orderly.