Positives:
We enjoyed our stay greatly. The view is incredible, the price was right, and the Celedon is a great place to stay. It's on the quieter side of the island, and we enjoyed the beach every day. You can rent chairs on the beach for a fee, or you can bring your own and just walk down past where the chairs are setup.
Negatives:
As other reviewers have noted, the blinds on the deck doors in both the living room and the master bedroom are broken. For the master bedroom, the blinds let a lot of light in early in the morning, but this wasn't a big deal as we were waking up early every day. For some, this might be a deal breaker.
As far as cleanliness goes, we found overall the rental was pretty clean. Everywhere "obvious" was very clean.. However, this is in bad need of a deep clean, this is another issue hinted at by other reviewers... There is visible dirt still on the floors under the beds, behind and beside night stands, and on fan blades.
Hopefully the owner will pay for a deep clean soon to fix this problem.
The blinds are broken due to previous renters not following instructions. The vertical blinds that are installed can easily get sucked out the deck door and broken. I would suggest getting rid of the blinds and replacing entirely with drapes.
Conclusion:
Even with these problems, my family and I would still stay there again so long as it was priced similarly. We really enjoyed our trip.