Find lake rentals near Old Mormon Print Shop Museum

We’ve stayed at many different places on the island and especially loved this one. The private beach looks out on lovely Lake Michigan with Garden Island on the horizon. It’s very relaxing and meditative. The location is perfect, with the sandy Donegal Bay Beach just down the road in one direction and the town of Saint James in the other. The apartment is filled with amenities, which include a towel warmer, a kitchen with everything you need, and plenty of storage for those who are staying the week. We highly recommend it and plan to return again.

I really like how spacious the house is! Definitely room for everyone to spread out or come together and play games! Very clean and comfortable beds.

This is the perfect spot for family time on Beaver Island: mergansers, loons, muscrats to keep us entertained. Beautiful sunsets and exciting thunderstorms on Lake G. Great place for swimming off the dock and kayaking to the North and South arms. Easy access to Cable and Iron Ore Bays. Our hosts are fantastic. The house is perfect for our family of 5. We will be counting the months til a 2026 return to The Lucky Charm. Thank you!

We have been staying at Cleveland’s Big Chill off and on for many years and it never disappoints. We love the beach access and quietness of the woods. Sarah is a great property manager and made sure our family was welcomed.

Blue Spruce Cottage is a beautiful house, very comfortable. We had everything we could possible need. Our host, Sarah, was great. Good communication and answered all our questions promptly. We would stay there again for sure!

Gorgeous beach on a beautiful location. House was clean, well stocked and comfortable as always! Thank you for sharing your lovely home!

This house exceeded all of our expectations and made for a wonderful weekend trip on Beaver Island. Becca and Bryan were so kind and let us know of all the events going on that weekend. The house was beautiful and very cozy, we will definitely be back!

Lovely home and fantastic location. Joshua and Kelley were so responsive. Would love to rent again next year!