Maison entière

Outdoor Living & Upscale Charm | Catskill Main Street | Beatrice by AvantStay

Galerie de photos de l’hébergement Outdoor Living & Upscale Charm | Catskill Main Street | Beatrice by AvantStay

Extérieur
Aire de séjour
Terrain de l’hébergement
Restauration
Terrasse/patio

Avis

10 sur 10, Aimé des clients
Parmi les hébergements les mieux notés par les voyageurs dans cette région.
5 chambres2 salles de bain ou plus10 personnes

Commodités populaires

  • Stationnement intérieur disponible
  • Animaux de compagnie acceptés
  • Cuisine
  • Laveuse
  • Climatisation
  • Barbecue

Explorez la région

Afficher sur la carte
Catskill, NY
  • Place, Greene County Council on the Arts
    ‪5 min à pied‬
  • Place, Site national historique Thomas Cole
    ‪19 min à pied‬
  • Place, Hudson River
    ‪2 min en voiture‬
  • Airport, Hudson, NY (HCC-Columbia County)
    ‪20 min en voiture‬

Chambres et lits

5 chambres (10 personnes)

Chambre 1

1 grand lit

Chambre 2

1 très grand lit

Chambre 3

1 grand lit

Chambre 4

1 grand lit

Chambre 5

2 lits 1 place

2 salles de bain, 1 salle avec toilette et lavabo

Salle de bain 1

Salle de bain 2

Salle de bain 3

Espaces supplémentaires

Terrasse en bois ou patio
Cuisine
Jardin
Salle à manger

À propos de cet hébergement

Outdoor Living & Upscale Charm | Catskill Main Street | Beatrice by AvantStay

An industrial-style kitchen, rustic brick details, and an abundance of charming, upscale style are just some of the surprises you'll find at Beatrice. This quaint yet spacious Catskills home has an expansive outdoor patio perfect for al fresco meals and lounging among the mountain air. Inside, you'll find gorgeous hardwood floors, a chic yet modern design, and two separate living rooms so everyone in your group can spread out. Lounge by the fireplace, take a seat at the piano, or whip up everyone's favorites in the open kitchen with an oversized range and sink. Each of the five bedrooms has been thoughtfully curated with comfortable beds and crisp, clean decor. You'll be surrounded by the beauty of the valley and minutes from the Hudson River. Beatrice is waiting to show your group a Catskill experience like never before!

AvantStay provides a personalized hospitality experience to elevate your stay. With our Concierge Service, guests have access to our tech-enabled services like fridge stocking, private chefs, massages, transportation, special occasion celebrations, baby gear rentals, ski gear, beach gear, and more. For anything you need, we’re at your fingertips!

It's no wonder city dwellers flock to upstate New York's Hudson Valley for a break from the daily grind. Its rural beauty and colorful foliage is a beautiful change of scenery. After all, it was here that inspired an entire artistic movement of Romantic painters to capture the area's rolling hills and pastoral setting. View the landscapes in person by hiking the Catskill Mountains, and then head to the farm to pick seasonal produce. Think apple picking in the fall and strawberries in the summer!

Local Attractions: Dutchman’s Landing Park, The Avalon Lounge, Cone E Island Ice Cream, Crossroads Brewing Company, Olana State Historic District, Gracie’s Luncheonette

Home Truths:
- This home allows pets for a fee. If undisclosed pets are brought into the home without AvantStay's approval there is a fine of $500 per pet.
- A pack-n-play and highchair are provided at this home.
- AC is available from the end of May to end of September, depending on the weather.
- Please note our occupancy includes an additional two beyond bed count. Trifold floor mattresses and additional linens can be provided upon request.

Parking Details:
There are 4 available parking spaces at the rear of the home.
The garage is not available for guest use.
Public municipal parking across the street

---

The room configuration is as follows:

Primary Bedroom / King bed
Bedroom 2 / Queen bed
Bedroom 3 / Queen bed
Bedroom 4 / Queen bed
Bedroom 5 / Two twin beds

---

This is a smoke-free property. Violation of the no-smoking policy will result in forfeiture of the security deposit, a $300 smoking fee, and liability for any fire or property damage costs.

As part of our commitment to being good neighbors, occupancy limits and quiet hours (9pm-8am) are strictly enforced. No speakers or sound systems will be provided for use in our properties. Violation of any noise ordinances will be subject to fines that can reach up to $10,000 per violation.

Events or parties are not allowed without prior written approval and an additional fee. Any unauthorized parties or events will be shut down and a fine will be assessed. Please inquire for more information about our event policies and fees.

There is nothing more important to us at AvantStay than the health, safety, and experience of our guests & staff. We've enhanced our cleaning and sanitation protocols and are taking extra care to disinfect all surfaces between reservations with hospital-grade disinfecting solutions.

As a reminder, we do work with 3rd party vendors to maintain the property, and although we adhere to the strictest CDC guidelines and advise all contractors to wear PPE equipment, we can not always enforce. We strongly advise guests to please deny access if any vendors fail to meet and adhere to these standards.

IDs will be requested for verification after booking. All bookings over 30 days require a security deposit.

We report and prosecute all Credit Card Fraud.

Ajoutez des dates pour connaître les prix

Hébergements similaires

Règles de l’hébergement

Arrivée après 16 h 00
Âge minimum pour la location : 21 ans
Départ avant 11 h 00
default

Enfants

Enfants autorisés : de 0 à 17 ans
default

Événements

Événements non autorisés
default

Animaux de compagnie

Animaux de compagnie autorisés
default

Fumeurs/non-fumeurs

Hébergement non-fumeurs

Renseignements importants

À savoir

Nº de l’hébergement : 3106023vb
Des frais pour toute personne supplémentaire peuvent être facturés et dépendent de la politique de l'hébergement
Une pièce d'identité officielle avec photo et un dépôt de garantie en espèces, par carte de crédit ou par carte de débit, peuvent être demandés à l'arrivée pour couvrir tous frais imprévus
Les demandes spéciales, qui ne peuvent pas être garanties, sont soumises à disponibilité à l'arrivée et peuvent entraîner des frais supplémentaires
Les fêtes et les événements de groupe sont interdits
L'hôte a indiqué que l'hébergement était équipé d'un détecteur de monoxyde de carbone
L'hôte a indiqué que l'hébergement était équipé d'un détecteur de fumée
Cet hébergement comprend les dispositifs de sécurité suivants : un extincteur, une trousse de secours et un verrou de sûreté

À propos du quartier

Catskill

Cette maison de vacances vous donne rendez-vous à Catskill, plus précisément à la montagne, en bord de rivière. Profitez de votre séjour dans la région pour visiter les célèbres Site national historique Thomas Cole et Kykuit, ou vous en mettre plein la vue aux emblématiques Lumberyard Contemporary Performing Arts et Greene County Council on the Arts. Envie de vivre un moment unique lors de votre séjour ? Consultez l'affiche des fantastiques Centre équestre HITS-on-the-Hudson et Kiwanis Ice Arena (patinoire), et préparez-vous à vibrer ! Envie de faire le plein d'aventures ? La région a pile ce qu'il vous faut ! Profitez de votre séjour pour vous adonner à des activités telles que la randonnée à pied ou à vélo.
Carte
Catskill, NY

À proximité

  • Greene County Council on the Arts - 5 min à pied - 0.4 km
  • Parc Dutchman's Landing - 15 min à pied - 1.3 km
  • Site national historique Thomas Cole - 19 min à pied - 1.6 km
  • Hudson River - 2 min en voiture - 1.8 km
  • RamsHorn-Livingston Sanctuary - 4 min en voiture - 2.5 km

Transport

  • Gare de Hudson - 9 min en voiture
  • Hudson, NY (HCC-Columbia County) - 21 min en voiture

Restaurants

  • ‪Dunkin' - ‬15 min à pied
  • ‪McDonald's - ‬17 min à pied
  • ‪Burger King - ‬2 min en voiture
  • ‪Ambrosia Diner - ‬3 min en voiture
  • ‪Pomodoro's Italian Eatery - ‬3 min en voiture

Foire aux questions

Outdoor Living & Upscale Charm | Catskill Main Street | Beatrice by AvantStay accepte-t-il les animaux de compagnie?

Oui, cet hébergement accepte les animaux de compagnie.

Combien cela coûte-t-il de séjourner à Outdoor Living & Upscale Charm | Catskill Main Street | Beatrice by AvantStay?

En date du 15 mai 2026, les prix trouvés pour un séjour d’une nuit pour deux adultes à l’hébergement Outdoor Living & Upscale Charm | Catskill Main Street | Beatrice by AvantStay le 8 déc. 2026 commencent à 339 $ CA, taxes et frais en sus. Ce prix est fondé sur le plus bas prix par nuit des 24 dernières heures pour des séjours dans les 30 prochains jours. Les prix sont sujets à changement. Choisissez vos dates pour obtenir des prix précis.

Combien coûte le stationnement à Outdoor Living & Upscale Charm | Catskill Main Street | Beatrice by AvantStay?

Un stationnement gratuit est disponible à proximité.

À quelle heure est-il possible d'arriver à Outdoor Living & Upscale Charm | Catskill Main Street | Beatrice by AvantStay?

L’arrivée est possible à partir de 16 h.

À quelle heure doit s'effectuer le départ à Outdoor Living & Upscale Charm | Catskill Main Street | Beatrice by AvantStay?

Le départ est à 11 h.

Où se situe Outdoor Living & Upscale Charm | Catskill Main Street | Beatrice by AvantStay?

Propriété de vacances se trouve au bord d’une rivière, à moins de 5 minutes de marche des sites suivants : Lumberyard Contemporary Performing Arts et Greene County Council on the Arts. Hudson River et Parc Dutchman's Landing se trouvent également à moins de 15 minutes de marche.

Avis

10

Exceptionnel

Les avis sont présentés en ordre chronologique, soumis à un processus de modération et vérifiés, à moins d’indication contraire.
En savoir plusS’ouvre dans une nouvelle fenêtre
Note de 10 – Excellent, d’après 20 avis sur 22.
Note de 8 – Bien, d’après 2 avis sur 22.
Note de 6 – Acceptable, d’après 0 avis sur 22.
Note de 4 – Médiocre, d’après 0 avis sur 22.
Note de 2 – Terrible, d’après 0 avis sur 22.

10/10

Propreté

10/10

Arrivée

9,6/10

Communication

10/10

Emplacement

10/10

Exactitude de l’annonce

Avis

Avis vérifié

10/10 – Excellent

Erin M.

Points forts : Propreté, arrivée, communication, emplacement, exactitude de l’annonce
Beautiful, spacious house. Perfect for a weekend away with friends and easy to walk to places in town.
Séjour de 2 nuits en mars 2026
VrboOwner a répondu le 10 mars 2026
Thank you for the kind review. We're glad you enjoyed the space and found the home comfortable for your weekend away with friends. It's great to hear the location made it easy to walk to spots around town. We’d be happy to host you again anytime.
Avis vérifié

10/10 – Excellent

ginny e.

Points forts : Propreté, arrivée, communication, emplacement, exactitude de l’annonce
Good stay east trip to Hudson for a wedding weekend
Séjour de 6 nuits en octobre 2025
VrboOwner a répondu le 27 oct. 2025
Thank you! We’re glad you had a good stay and that the location worked well for your Hudson wedding weekend.
Avis vérifié

10/10 – Excellent

Sarah D.

Points forts : Propreté, arrivée, communication, emplacement, exactitude de l’annonce
We loved this house! It was beautiful, comfortable, and the perfect jumping off point for a long weekend in the Hudson Valley. The location is perfect with coffee shops, stores, and bars only a few minutes walk away, and it was a quick drive to Hudson, Olana, and beautiful hiking. The hosts were very helpful and quick to respond with the couple of questions we had.
Séjour de 4 nuits en octobre 2025
VrboOwner a répondu le 4 nov. 2025
Thank you so much for your lovely review! We’re thrilled to hear you loved the house and found it comfortable and convenient for exploring the Hudson Valley. It’s great to know the location, nearby amenities, and quick access to Hudson, Olana, and hiking trails added to your weekend. We’re glad we could assist with your questions, and we’d be delighted to host you again!
Avis vérifié

10/10 – Excellent

Adrianna P.

Points forts : Propreté, arrivée, communication, emplacement, exactitude de l’annonce

Wonderful

Had an absolutely wonderful stay here. Such a beautiful home!
Séjour de 3 nuits en octobre 2023
VrboOwner a répondu le 23 févr. 2024
Thank you, Adrianna! We're thrilled that you had an absolutely wonderful stay and found the home beautiful. We hope to have the pleasure of hosting you again in the future!
Avis vérifié

10/10 – Excellent

Stephanie A.

Points forts : Propreté, arrivée, communication, emplacement, exactitude de l’annonce

Incredible stay

Cannot wait to go back. House was bigger and nicer in person and extremely clean. Our entire group said they want to stay here again. Will always stay at an AvantStay from now on!
Séjour de 3 nuits en octobre 2024
VrboOwner a répondu le 7 nov. 2024
Thank you, Stephanie, for your amazing review! We’re thrilled to hear that the house exceeded your expectations and that your entire group had a great experience. We’re so happy to have earned your trust, and we can’t wait to welcome you back for your next stay. We’ll be here whenever you're ready for your next AvantStay getaway!
Avis vérifié

10/10 – Excellent

Jonathan C.

Points forts : Propreté, arrivée, communication, emplacement, exactitude de l’annonce

Stunning Property

Great location in Catskill. Walk to everything. Well maintained and appointed. Kitchen is ready for large groups.
Séjour de 2 nuits en mai 2025
VrboOwner a répondu le 20 mai 2025
Thank you for the kind words, Jonathan. We're glad you enjoyed the location and found the home well-maintained and equipped, especially the kitchen for group gatherings. We appreciate you staying with us and hope to host you again soon.
Avis vérifié

10/10 – Excellent

Tony C.

Points forts : Propreté, arrivée, communication, emplacement, exactitude de l’annonce

Great place for large group

Beautiful home. Accommodated 10 people no problem
Séjour de 2 nuits en décembre 2023
VrboOwner a répondu le 13 déc. 2023
Thank you for your positive feedback, Tony! We're thrilled to hear that you found the home beautiful and that it comfortably accommodated your group of 10 people. We appreciate your review and hope to have the pleasure of hosting you again.
Avis vérifié

10/10 – Excellent

Elizabeth K.

Points forts : Propreté, arrivée, communication, emplacement, exactitude de l’annonce

Rhinebeck Weekend

wonderful! But could use better lighting in the living room.
Séjour de 4 nuits en octobre 2024
VrboOwner a répondu le 1 nov. 2024
Thank you for the lovely review, Elizabeth! We’re glad to hear you had a wonderful stay. We appreciate your feedback about the lighting in the living room and will certainly look into it. We hope to welcome you back for another great visit!
Avis vérifié

10/10 – Excellent

David C.

Points forts : Propreté, arrivée, communication, emplacement, exactitude de l’annonce

A great stay

We were 2 families with kids ranging from 9 - 15 years old. We had a wonderful stay at Beatrice. The location was great. Many places to walk and eat and explore within walking distance. Jeff was a wonderful host, very communicative and helpful throughout our stay. The place was big. We really liked the tall ceilings and the space, which was great for our dogs. Highly recommend!
Séjour de 3 nuits en février 2025
VrboOwner a répondu le 24 févr. 2025
Thank you, David! We're so glad your families had a wonderful stay and that the location, space, and tall ceilings made it comfortable for everyone—including your dogs! Jeff will be happy to hear your kind words about his hospitality. We appreciate your recommendation and hope to welcome you back in the future!
Avis vérifié

10/10 – Excellent

Ajay K.

Points forts : Propreté, arrivée, communication, emplacement, exactitude de l’annonce

Excellent stay

One of the few times that the home was more impressive than the pictures. It was a lovely stay. Only thing I could suggest would be to have more pots and pans for cooking.
Séjour de 3 nuits en juillet 2023
VrboOwner a répondu le 5 août 2023
Thank you for your kind words! We're thrilled that you enjoyed your stay and found the home impressive. Your feedback about the pots and pans is noted, and we'll make sure to improve our kitchen amenities for future guests. We hope to host you again in the future for another wonderful stay.
Avis vérifié

10/10 – Excellent

Jane A.

Points forts : Propreté, arrivée, communication, emplacement, exactitude de l’annonce

Great stay in Catskill!

Lovely stay in this beautifully furnished historic home, there was plenty of space and the bedrooms are so roomy. It was a little chilly in the morning and we enjoyed the gas fireplace. Our family was in town for a theater event and this was the perfect location. Main Street has lots of shops and restaurants ans we had breakfast at Willa’s twice-don’t miss it!
Séjour de 4 nuits en mai 2023
Avis vérifié

10/10 – Excellent

Erin D.

Points forts : Propreté, arrivée, communication, emplacement, exactitude de l’annonce

A Stay With Style

Beatrice is beautiful inside and out. The stylish space has so much room for a family or group to spread out. Beds and linens were especially comfortable but the true star is the sprawling porch. It's a quick walk to Catskill shops, restaurants, and cafes. We can't wait to come back!
Séjour de 3 nuits en avril 2023
VrboOwner a répondu le 25 avr. 2023
Thank you for the great review, Erin! We’re so happy you loved your stay, and we're looking forward to hosting you again soon.
Avis vérifié

10/10 – Excellent

Molly M.

Points forts : Propreté, arrivée, communication, emplacement, exactitude de l’annonce

Home away from home

We had an amazing stay at this property. We were there for work and my team and I really enjoyed how spacious, clean and accommodating this property was to all of our needs. We especially appreciated having the groceries delivered to the house before we arrived. We would definitely rent this property again.
Séjour de 4 nuits en août 2023
Avis vérifié

10/10 – Excellent

Amanda T.

Points forts : Propreté, arrivée, communication, emplacement, exactitude de l’annonce

Review

We had a lovely stay. Plenty of room & beautiful updates to make this home cozy. Love the lighting through the house. Only thing we couldn’t find was a brush for outdoor grill. Definitely would stay again.
Séjour de 3 nuits en février 2024
VrboOwner a répondu le 30 avr. 2024
Hi Amanda, Thank you for the lovely review! We're glad you enjoyed your stay and found the home cozy with beautiful updates. We appreciate your feedback about the outdoor grill brush and will ensure it's provided for future guests. We look forward to hosting you again!
Avis vérifié

10/10 – Excellent

Megan C.

Points forts : Propreté, arrivée, communication, emplacement, exactitude de l’annonce

Christmas

This property was great! Spacious, clean and comfortable for everyone. We totally enjoyed our stay and are planning on coming back again. So easy to communicate with the property managers.
Séjour de 5 nuits en décembre 2022
VrboOwner a répondu le 17 janv. 2023
Megan, we are happy to hear that you will be coming back and, more importantly, we're happy to hear that you had such a wonderful time. Thank you for staying with us, and we look forward to hosting you again soon.
Avis vérifié

10/10 – Excellent

Deirdre A.

Points forts : Propreté, arrivée, communication, emplacement, exactitude de l’annonce

Great house for groups

Well restored old house with large living and dining areas great for groups. Good location on the edge of cute downtown Catskill, with a short drive to Hudson. Even though it’s right by downtown it was very quiet at night. My only suggestions would be more minor creature comforts- some throw blankets and more floor/tabletop lighting in the living rooms, and better toilet paper.
Séjour de 3 nuits en janvier 2023
VrboOwner a répondu le 5 juin 2023
We love hearing feedback from our guests! Thank you for taking the time to review!
Avis vérifié

8/10 – Bien

Margaret C.

Points forts : Propreté, arrivée, communication, emplacement, exactitude de l’annonce

Beatrice—the house is large and somewhat well furnished.

The house is large and somewhat well furnished as a group of professionals we would have appreciated small tables and a chair akin to the one in the kitchen for our laptops in the bedrooms. In addition a bench at the bottom of the beds to put the multitudinous decorative pillows. There was dust and grit in the bedroom dresser drawers. Also there needs to be better lighting coming down the stairs from the parking spaces.
Séjour de 7 nuits en juin 2023
Avis vérifié

10/10 – Excellent

Nancy K.

Points forts : Propreté, arrivée, communication, emplacement, exactitude de l’annonce

Christmas in Catskill

Wonderful stay for Christmas holidays gathering. Plenty of room for families to spread out or be together. Two lovely gathering rooms and hosts provided surprise Christmas tree in living room with cozy fireplace and a piano for entertainment. Moved back and forth between TV room for movies, games and puzzles. (Great selection of books and games.) Beautifully restored historic home with impeccable decor. Perfect mix of modern and period with just the right touches, no clutter, which we appreciate. Kitchen accoutrements provided everything necessary for numerous holiday feasts enjoyed in the large, ambient dining room. A few minutes walk down the street are shops, eats and drinks for daily outings. Beautiful home, comfortable beds, all needs provided for. Perfect score!
Séjour de 4 nuits en décembre 2023
VrboOwner a répondu le 21 mars 2024
Thank you for your wonderful review, Nancy! We're thrilled you enjoyed your Christmas holiday gathering in our historic home. It's fantastic to hear that the space, amenities, and decor exceeded your expectations. We appreciate your kind words and hope to welcome you back for another perfect stay soon!
Avis vérifié

10/10 – Excellent

Mary Ann M.

Points forts : Propreté, arrivée, communication, emplacement, exactitude de l’annonce

Beautiful House Inside - Outside needs a lot of work

This house was wonderful inside, but the grounds need work. The railings on the front steps and the back steps leading to the parking spaces are dangerous and need to be fixed immediately before someone falls and gets injured. The landscaping in the front and the back of the house need a LOT of work. There are numerous "volunteer" trees that need to be removed. There are some beautiful flowers and bushes in the front and back of the house that are being overtaken by weeds and overgrowth. All of this detracts from the beauty of the house and should be addressed ASAP.
Séjour de 4 nuits en juin 2024
Avis vérifié

8/10 – Bien

Roberta S.

Points forts : Propreté, emplacement et exactitude de l’annonce.
Points faibles : Communication

Great spot to explore upper Hudson River Balley

This house is spacious, clean, and ideally suited for exploring the upper Hudson Valley. Located in the center of the town of Catskill, it is quiet, and convenient to locations on both river banks. Great for large groups or families. I have been a VRBO renter for over a decade. This particular rental property has a more involved registration process than I have thus far encountered. It includes a lengthy contract, an uploaded government identification document, and facial identification. Unfortunately, the facial identification would not allow IOS software and thus required tech help and an alternate device. Unfortunately, these latter requirements were revealed only days before entry to the property, and were time consuming.
Séjour de 4 nuits en juin 2023
Avis vérifié

10/10 – Excellent

Ray W.

Points forts : Propreté, arrivée, communication, emplacement, exactitude de l’annonce

Spacious house in river town

The house is rather ostentatious for this small town of artists and working class people. Located next to a church on one side and a tattoo parlor on the other with some vacant lots across the street. However, at edge of a lovely downtown with variety of shops and restaurants within walking distance. Decor is on the minimalist side - mix of a few antiques and mostly modern furnishings. All mechanical systems worked well, except shower in the master bedroom which was difficult to operate without getting the whole bathroom wet. Oddly, there were no screens in any of the windows. The weather was so nice we did open the windows after some hesitation and had no problem with insects. So maybe that's why there were no screens. Many window panes have original wavy glass which is saying that is wavy. Parking is convenient to the rear of the house. There is a back and side yard which is almost completely fenced in for pets except for about a 10-ft gap where there had been fencing at one time. I don't know why they wouldn't put some wire fencing across that since the posts are already there and then it would be much easier to bring your pets. There was some poison ivy by the path in the backyard that needs to be removed. Well stocked kitchen including things like coffee and tea. We bought measuring cups since we did some baking and left them for the next person.
Séjour de 4 nuits en août 2023
Avis vérifié

10/10 – Excellent

Andrew T.

Points forts : Propreté, arrivée, communication, emplacement, exactitude de l’annonce
Everything was very clean, organized, and parking was easy.
Séjour de 2 nuits en avril 2026
VrboOwner a répondu le 28 avr. 2026
Thank you for the kind review! We're so glad to hear the home was clean, well-organized, and that parking was a breeze — those little details really do make a difference. It's wonderful to know your stay went smoothly from start to finish. We'd love to welcome you back anytime!

À propos de l’hôte

Hôte : AvantStay

Image de profil de l’hôte
At AvantStay, we pride ourselves on our guest experience. We do the trip planning - so you can spend more time on vacation. With 24/7 customer support, a dedicated concierge, and tech-enabled touchpoints from the moment you book to an easy and seamless check-out, we make your experience as carefree as you could possibly want it to be. AvantStay features 500 homes in 30+ destinations and is growing quickly. For any questions about your next trip, please don't hesitate to reach out directly and we'd be more than happy to help your vacation come true.

Langue(s) :

Anglais

Hôte de choix

Nos hôtes de choix offrent des expériences hors pair aux vacanciers.
Dites-nous comment nous pouvons améliorer notre site.Partager mes commentaires