7Bedroom 4Bath Center of the strip. Great view from the front porch. Pet Friendy
About Matt Caudill
Hello, we are CM Investments. PJ Macchia and Matt Caudill. We have come together to bring you the best rental on Geneva on the Lake Ohio.
Matt Caudill purchased this House in 1970
Why Matt Caudill chose Geneva-on-the-Lake
PJ was born and raised in the Village of Geneva on the Lake. His father purchased the house in 1970 and has been a monthly renal ever since. PJ and Matt decided to renovate the entire house top to bottom and offer it to vacationers of Geneva on the Lake
What makes this House unique
You will enjoy the entire house to yourself and be within walking distance of the entire strip.
Max guests: 20
Minimum age of primary renter: 21
100% refund if canceled at least 30 days before arrival date. 50% refund if canceled at least 14 days before arrival date.
Damage and incidentals
You will be responsible for any damage to the rental property caused by you or your party during your stay.
We had a lot of fun renting out this rental can’t wait to come back during the summer.
Wine Country Getaway
Great place for 5 couples to gather for a weekend enjoying all the vineyards in Ashtabula Country
A Wonderful Place to Celebrate Life
In the belly of this beloved structure lay a thousand stories unwritten, awaiting to be discovered (or remembered) in every room. Laughter echoes throughout the hallways, the sounds of footprints running up the stairways, and the enchanting smells of garnished entrees lining the long, elegant dining table.
The Colonial may have old bones, but it is alive and well, and full of the memories of generations who have loved, cried, danced, and contemplated under its roof. The home itself is vast and full of character, including a 3-bowl farmhouse-style sink, large bathrooms, and sofa-beds galore. The home had every amenity we needed.
We had the great opportunity of spending Christmas in this magnificent relic of a time long past with our 3 dogs, and our beloved cockatiel, Aries, who unfortunately passed away yesterday in his sleep. The last photo I took with him was in the dining room of The Colonial, forever a place where the memories of a life that passed me by once was.
It was the largest home we have ever stayed in as a family, and it was very easy to get lost in the endless bedrooms and 3 floors. My Aunt Nancy went out on the front porch in the early morning hours and was locked out until my husband went out to say hello around 9 am. We had quite the Christmas feast, although most of our family could not make it to be with us. We made the best of what we had.
I just want to make a note regarding this, but I'm not sure if it's a thing they do every year... but to our great surprise, the entire home was already decorated for Christmas. I can't even tell you how much it meant to us to see such a beautiful home decorated to the nine's. It meant everything.
We are so grateful for our time at The Colonial, and we leave with it the memories we made, the laughter that bellowed throughout the halls, and our footprints that we leave scattered on the stairways.
Great place to stay with a group, we will definitely go back again next year.
This place has so much charm, love the old house feel with all the new house amenities.
Colonial Geneva on the Lake, Ohio
Very large rooming house with a lot of history. Everything worked well, was clean and we had a great time. If you have a large group this is a good place to stay. Recommend not staying during cooler weather if you like it warm. The central heating system doesn't work and there are a lot of pieced together heaters throughout the house to take it's place. Also keep in mind the outdoor patio and bar next door are very loud at night.
Geneva on the Lake, located on the shores of Lake Erie, is Ohio's first Summer resort! Families have enjoyed vacationing here on America's northcoast for generations. Here's additional information about our history.
During the summer season, our famous entertainment Strip is alive with arcades, amusement rides, restaurants, nightclubs, live music and more. Lake Erie offers fishing, boating, and swimming -- often with just a short walk from your front door.
You can shoot a round of golf at one of our in-town or area golf courses. For family fun try one of our many minature golf courses.
We offer wineries and sunsets, too, along with just the right summer breeze. Arriving by boat? Dock within the safety of the harbor at nearby Geneva State Park.
Geneva on the Lake, Ashtabula County, Ohio, is an old-fashioned lakefront getaway that has something for everyone. Explore our site. Explore Geneva on the Lake. We're confident we have an activity for you.