When considering a vacation rental in Oakdale, New York, the best area to stay is near the picturesque waterfront. This charming neighborhood offers a serene atmosphere, making it ideal for relaxation while still being close to local attractions. The scenic views along the Great South Bay are great for leisurely walks, and you can enjoy outdoor activities such as kayaking or boating.Another appealing aspect of this area is its proximity to the historic Oakdale Village, which features quaint shops and eateries that capture the local charm. Additionally, you'll find the beautiful Connetquot River State Park Preserve nearby, offering miles of trails for hiking and ample opportunities for birdwatching. While the exact number of properties can vary, the waterfront area generally has a nice selection of vacation rentals that cater to different preferences, ensuring you can find a great spot for your stay.