My family (myself, 2 daughters, 1 son-in-law, 4 granddaughter) spent 2 weeks here. We really enjoyed it. The owners can easily improve it even more by addressing the few negatives below.
Positive:
Property manager was very responsive and addressed every question/concern immediately.
Best Equipped/supplied rental I've been to (and I've been to a LOT).
Kitchen fully updated, very nice.
Property was in an excellent location between Key Largo and Key West. Day trips were easy. We're an on-the-go family and were out every day except one (a rest day). State parks are also close.
Location in neighborhood was very nice, peaceful.
Son-in-law had a blast fishing from the deck in the canal.
Teen girls (4 of them 13 to 16) took over the lower level and loved the privacy (so did we!).
Loved the ice machine on top deck!
Negatives:
Owners controlled the upstairs air remotely and had programmed the temp to go up at set intervals. I complained to the property owner as we were getting up several times a night sweating. She conveyed it to the owners. It improved for a few days but was back after that even worse. We'd set the temp at 70 (it definitely didn't reach that temp in the bedrooms, but was much warmer), and start feeling warm 30 minutes later and it'd be back to 76 . Night times were the most frustrating as we'd wake up sweating and have to go turn it down again. Note: The lower level was window air and as long as the girls kept the blinds drawn, it was very nice downstairs.
General Complaint:
A washing machine that I tried to use then realized it wasn't plugged in and wouldn't work when I plugged it in. There was also a working washer/dryer.
There was a TV on the upstairs deck and a TV above the pool under the deck. We were happy about movie night by the pool. But neither TV worked. They were not advertised.
Get rid of non-working appliances.
The 3rd bedroom upstairs:
* It was hot. The Property Manager supplied a fan and it helped, but it was noticeably warmer than the other bedrooms.
* The bed frame in the bedroom broke 2 times. I do have pictures of the original as well as the repairs. It had obviously broken multiple times before as it had old "McGiver-type" repairs with pieces of wood bracing it, etc.
* The mattress was old, very old. It was the type with the bare springs covered with material. They don't even make that type anymore. It was horribly uncomfortable.
* The entire bed/bedframe needs to be replaced.