Old Settlers vacation rentals
We found 66 vacation rentals — enter your dates for availability
Find spaces that suit your style
House
Condo/Apartment
Find the best place to stay - Old Settlers

Sunrise in Surf City
3 bedrooms · 2 bathrooms
exceptional
(11 reviews)
Top rated rentals - Old Settlers

Perfect for Family Thanksgiving!
exceptional
(5 reviews)
Rating Details:
The property manager was very helpful.
The vacation rental was spotless.
I was very happy with the location.
I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
We had a wonderful extended family visit at this beautiful property for Thanksgiving. The house is gorgeous, roomy and incredibly well provisioned. It was perfect for our group - everything you could need in the kitchen, two refrigerators, an amazing stove/oven and abundant dining and seating space, both indoor and outdoor. Beds were super comfy and it was so nice to have private baths for every room. The basement was also a great spot to relax and play ping pong/darts for both kids and adults. It's a quick walk to the beach and has a brand new dock on the canal side. Highly recommended!
Katherine M.
Stayed Nov 2025
- Peace of mindOur Book with Confidence guarantee gives you 24/7 support
- All the privacy of homeEnjoy full kitchens, laundry, pools, yards and more
- More for lessMore space, more privacy, more amenities — more value
More Vacation Ideas
- Escape Spa Vacation Rentals
- Inis Spa Vacation Rentals
- Ohana Paddle Sports Vacation Rentals
- Surf Condos Vacation Rentals
- Thomas Tackle and Seafood Vacation Rentals
- Topsail Skating Rink Topsail Beach Vacation Rentals
- Mia's Marketplace Vacation Rentals
- Summer Winds Vacation Rentals
- Sneads Ferry Vacation Rentals
- Back in Touch Massage Vacation Rentals
- Village of Stump Sound Vacation Rentals
- Cape Island Vacation Rentals
- St. Regis Resort Vacation Rentals
- Emerald Isle Vacation Rentals
- Scotch Bonnet Soundside Vacation Rentals
- Seaview Pier Vacation Rentals
- Topsail Island Vacation Rentals
- Wilmington Vacation Rentals
- Ocean City Beach Vacation Rentals
- Surf City Pier Vacation Rentals
- Carolina Beach Vacation Rentals
- Ocean Ridge Vacation Rentals
- Villas By the Sea Vacation Rentals
- Wrightsville Beach Vacation Rentals
- Figure Eight Island Vacation Rentals
- Surf City Vacation Rentals
- Ocean Sound Village Vacation Rentals
- Seacoast Art Gallery Vacation Rentals
- Island Oaks Vacation Rentals
- Rogers Bay Vacation Rentals
- Sea Coast Suites Vacation Rentals
- Sea Star Village Vacation Rentals
- Topsail Dunes Vacation Rentals
- Topsail Beach Vacation Rentals
- Sloop Point Plantation Vacation Rentals
- Southside Park Vacation Rentals
- Turtle Cove Vacation Rentals
- Live Oaks of Topsail Vacation Rentals
- Oak Island Vacation Rentals
- Villa Capriani Resort Vacation Rentals
- Holly Ridge Vacation Rentals
- North Topsail Beach Vacation Rentals
- Pet-Friendly rentals in Cape Island
- Rentals with pool in Cape Island
- Beach rentals in Topsail Island
- Cabin rentals in Topsail Island
- Condo rentals in Topsail Island
- Cottage rentals in Topsail Island
- Family rentals in Topsail Island
- Rentals with hot tubs in Topsail Island
- House rentals in Topsail Island
- Oceanfront rentals in Topsail Island
- Pet-Friendly rentals in Topsail Island
- Rentals with pool in Topsail Island
- Villa rentals in Topsail Island
- Condo rentals in Ocean City Beach
- House rentals in Ocean City Beach
- Oceanfront rentals in Ocean City Beach
- Pet-Friendly rentals in Ocean City Beach
- Beach rentals in Surf City
- Condo rentals in Surf City
- Cottage rentals in Surf City
- Family rentals in Surf City
- Rentals with hot tubs in Surf City
- House rentals in Surf City
- Lodge rentals in Surf City
- Oceanfront rentals in Surf City
- Pet-Friendly rentals in Surf City
- Rentals with pool in Surf City
- Villa rentals in Surf City
- Rentals with pool in Ocean Sound Village
- Condo rentals in Sea Coast Suites
- Condo rentals in Topsail Beach
- Oceanfront rentals in Topsail Beach
- Pet-Friendly rentals in Topsail Beach
- Rentals with pool in Topsail Beach
- Condo rentals in Villa Capriani Resort
- Family rentals near Villa Capriani Resort
- Rentals with pool near Villa Capriani Resort
- Beach rentals in Holly Ridge
- Cabin rentals in Holly Ridge
- Condo rentals in Holly Ridge
- Cottage rentals in Holly Ridge
- Family rentals in Holly Ridge
- Rentals with hot tubs in Holly Ridge
- House rentals in Holly Ridge
- Oceanfront rentals in Holly Ridge
- Pet-Friendly rentals in Holly Ridge
- Rentals with pool in Holly Ridge
- Townhouse rentals in Holly Ridge
- Beach rentals in North Topsail Beach
- Condo rentals in North Topsail Beach
- Family rentals in North Topsail Beach
- Rentals with hot tubs in North Topsail Beach
- House rentals in North Topsail Beach
- Lake rentals in North Topsail Beach
- Oceanfront rentals in North Topsail Beach
- Pet-Friendly rentals in North Topsail Beach
- Rentals with pool in North Topsail Beach
- Villa rentals in North Topsail Beach










